This is the part that trips up almost everyone. Most of the famous Cuban brand names also exist as completely separate cigars made in the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, and Honduras. They are legal, often good, and not Cuban.
Here is how that happened. After the revolution, Cuba nationalized its cigar factories in 1960. Several owners left the island, and they or American companies registered the old brand names in the United States, where the embargo kept the Cuban originals off the market. H. Upmann and Montecristo are the classic example: the Menéndez family lost its factory in 1960, kept making cigars under those names outside Cuba, and the US rights ended up with the company that became Altadis U.S.A. Cohiba's US trademark has been fought over in court between Cuba's tobacco company and General Cigar for decades.
The result is two parallel brand worlds sharing names. In the Cigarista catalog, Montecristo has 22 Cuban lines and 43 non-Cuban ones. Sometimes even the line names match: there is a Cuban Partagás Serie D No. 4 and a Nicaraguan Partagas Serie D No. 4, and a Cuban Bolívar Belicosos Finos alongside a Honduran Bolivar Belicosos Finos.
Telling them apart is simpler than it sounds. If you bought it in a US shop or from a US website legally, it is not Cuban. Cuban cigars come in boxes with the Habanos seal and the Cuban government warranty seal, and the box is stamped Hecho en Cuba. Non-Cuban versions usually say where they were made on the box, and they often carry line names that never existed in Cuba, like Montecristo White or Cohiba Red Dot. If a band in your hand leaves you unsure, scanning it in Cigarista pulls up the exact line and its origin from the catalog, which answers the Cuban-or-not question in a couple of seconds.
Same brand name, two different cigars (lines from the Cigarista catalog)| Brand name | Cuban line example | Non-Cuban line example | Catalog lines: Cuban / non-Cuban |
|---|
| Montecristo | No. 4 (Cuba, medium-full) | Montecristo White (Dominican Republic, mild) | 22 / 43 |
|---|
| Cohiba | Siglo VI (Cuba, medium-full) | Cohiba Red Dot (Dominican Republic, medium) | 23 / 20 |
|---|
| Romeo y Julieta | Churchills (Cuba, medium) | Romeo y Julieta 1875 (Dominican Republic, mild) | 33 / 40 |
|---|
| H. Upmann | Magnum 46 (Cuba, medium) | H. Upmann The Banker (Nicaragua, medium) | 19 / 22 |
|---|
| Hoyo de Monterrey | Epicure No. 2 (Cuba, mild) | Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur (Honduras, mild) | 28 / 22 |
|---|
| Punch | Punch Punch (Cuba, medium) | Punch Rare Corojo (Honduras, medium-full) | 28 / 40 |
|---|
| Partagás | Serie D No. 4 (Cuba, full) | Partagas Serie D No. 4 (Nicaragua, full) | 34 / 24 |
|---|
| Bolívar | Belicosos Finos (Cuba, full) | Bolivar Belicosos Finos (Honduras, full) | 38 / 10 |
|---|
| La Gloria Cubana | Medaille d'Or No. 2 (Cuba, medium) | La Gloria Cubana Serie R (Dominican Republic, full) | 12 / 34 |
|---|
Are Montecristo cigars Cuban?
Some are and some are not. Cuban Montecristos, like the No. 2 and No. 4, are made in Cuba by Habanos S.A. Montecristos sold legally in the United States, like the White, Classic, or Platinum, are separate cigars made mainly in the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua under a US trademark. If you bought it legally in the US, it is not Cuban.
Are the Cohibas sold in the US real?
They are real cigars, but they are not Cuban. Cohibas sold legally in the United States, such as Cohiba Red Dot, Blue, or Black, are made in the Dominican Republic and other countries by General Cigar under a US trademark that Cuba has contested in court for decades. A Cuban Cohiba cannot legally be bought in the US.