Cigarista Member

Member Since

JAN 2026

@maxshifman — cigar collection & reviews

Public profile

The Private Ledger

@maxshifmankeeps their cigar photos private. What follows is the public record of their taste — in their own words.

The Collection

11 cigars, mostly from Honduras, with a taste for honduran natural (dark) Churchills.

Cigars

Reviewed

3.8

Avg Rating

—

Streak

Ratings

2 of 11 reviewed

3.8

Overall

of 5.0

Craftsmanship

3.8

Aroma & Flavor

3.8

Enjoyment

3.8

Distribution of Reviews50% rated 4★ or higher

1★

2★

3★

4★

5★

Top Brands

Alec Bradley

1 cigar · 1 reviewed

2.5

Partagas

1 cigar · 1 reviewed

5.0

Collection DNA

what they reach for

Origin

Honduras

50%·1 cigar

Nicaragua50%

Wrapper

Honduran Natural (Dark)

50%·1 cigar

Habano50%

Shape

Churchill

50%·1 cigar

Double Corona50%

Activity & Growth

Review Streak

days
running

Personal best: 1

Growth

This Month

This Year

2.0

Avg / Mo

Pace

Last reviewed6 days ago

Last added6 days ago

Total reviews2

The Reviews

№ 01·JUN 10, 2026·Partagas·Double Corona

Lusitania

5.0Would smoke again

excellent constructiongood burnwell-made

Full review

№ 02·JUN 10, 2026·Alec Bradley·Churchill

Prensado Lost Art

2.5Would smoke again

Full review

The @maxshifman Index

Humidor

11cigars

What they own right now

By brand

Alec Bradley1

Partagas1

Notable holdings

Track your own collection

Identify any cigar, log your ratings, and curate your humidor. Cigarista is free to start; premium unlocks 35 IDs a month.