Cigarista Member

Member Since

AUG 2025

@mark.macdonough — cigar collection & reviews

Item: H. Upmann 1844
Rating: 2.8333332538604736

Public profile

The Private Ledger

@mark.macdonoughkeeps their cigar photos private. What follows is the public record of their taste — in their own words.

The Collection

2 cigars, mostly from Nicaragua.

Cigars

Reviewed

3.6

Avg Rating

—

Streak

Ratings

2 of 2 reviewed

3.6

Overall

of 5.0

Craftsmanship

3.5

Aroma & Flavor

3.3

Enjoyment

4.0

Distribution of Reviews50% rated 4★ or higher

1★

2★

3★

4★

5★

Top Brands

Drew Estate

1 cigar · 1 reviewed

4.3

H. Upmann

1 cigar · 1 reviewed

2.8

Collection DNA

what they reach for

Origin

Nicaragua

100%·2 cigars

Wrapper

Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro

100%·1 cigar

Activity & Growth

Review Streak

days
running

Personal best: 1

Growth

This Month

This Year

0.2

Avg / Mo

Pace

Last reviewed9 months ago

Last added9 months ago

Total reviews2

The Reviews

№ 01·AUG 29, 2025·Drew Estate

Liga Privada

4.3

well constructedfirm ashtight seams

Full review

№ 02·AUG 29, 2025·H. Upmann

1844

2.8

easy smoke needs a slit cut not a straight cut

Full review

The @mark.macdonough Index

Humidor

2cigars

What they own right now

By brand

Drew Estate1

H. Upmann1

Notable holdings

Track your own collection

Identify any cigar, log your ratings, and curate your humidor. Cigarista is free to start; premium unlocks 35 IDs a month.