Cigarista Member

@joshua.magalski — cigar collection & reviews

JO
Joined September 2026
The Case8 honors earned
Podium ever · Rising
Hall of fame
Top 10 ever · Reviewers
Hall of fame
Top 10 ever · On Fire
Hall of fame
10
Ten Reviews
Reviews
Board Fixture · Rising
Boards
Board Regular · Reviewers
Boards
Board Honors5 earned
Podium ever · Rising
Reached the podium (#3) on the Rising board.
Hall of fame
Top 10 ever · Reviewers
Reached the top ten (#10) on the Reviewers board.
Hall of fame
Top 10 ever · On Fire
Reached the top ten (#5) on the On Fire board.
Hall of fame
Board Fixture · Rising
Appeared on the Rising board 20× or more.
Boards
Board Regular · Reviewers
Appeared on the Reviewers board 5× or more.
Boards
Milestones3 earned
10
Ten Reviews
Published 10 reviews.
Reviews
Brand Curious
Logged cigars from 10 distinct brands.
Palate
Three-Origin Palate
Smoked across 3 countries of origin.
Palate
Every seal in @joshua.magalski’s case is earned, never given.
Climb the boards

The Collection

24 cigars, mostly from Nicaragua, with a taste for habano Toros.
24
Cigars
22
Reviewed
3.2
Avg Rating
—
Streak

Grails

4 cigars
Grail No. 1
Padrón
4000 Series
4.0
Padron
Padron 1964 Anniversary Maduro
The Tabernacle
The Tabernacle
Espinosa
Knuckle Sandwich saguaro

Ratings

22 of 24 reviewed
3.2
Overall
of 5.0
Craftsmanship
3.2
Aroma & Flavor
3.1
Enjoyment
3.3
Distribution of Reviews23% rated 4★ or higher
17
5
1★
2★
3★
4★
5★

Top Brands

1
Padron
2 cigars · 2 reviewed
3.6
2
Don Pepin Garcia
2 cigars · 2 reviewed
3.1
3
Davidoff
2 cigars · 2 reviewed
3.3
4
Room 101
2 cigars · 2 reviewed
3.2
5
My Father
2 cigars · 2 reviewed
3.0

Collection DNA

what they reach for

Origin

Nicaragua
64%·14 cigars
Dominican Republic18%
Honduras14%

Wrapper

Habano
20%·3 cigars
Maduro13%
Connecticut Broadleaf13%

Shape

Toro
48%·10 cigars
Robusto24%
Corona5%

Activity & Growth

Review Streak

0
days
running
Personal best: 2

Growth

+0
This Month
+22
This Year
10.9
Avg / Mo

Pace

Last reviewed2 weeks ago
Last addedA week ago
Total reviews22

Latest reviews

Room 101
Room 101 The Big Payback Nicaragua
Toro
3.3
excellent constructiongood burneasy draw
Oct 21, 2026
American Viking
Box Pressed Rebellion
Toro
3.0
excellent constructioneasy drawgood burn
Oct 17, 2026
Espinosa
Knuckle Sandwich saguaro
Toro
4.1
excellent constructiongood burneasy draw
Oct 17, 2026
Padrón
4000 Series
Toro
4.0Would smoke again
excellent constructiongood burneasy draw
Oct 10, 2026
Punch
Punch Elites Maduro
Corona
2.6
excellent constructiongood burn
Oct 10, 2026
Davidoff
Davidoff Dominicana
Short Robusto
3.0
excellent constructiongood burnsweet
Oct 3, 2026

More from @joshua.magalski

Humidor
What they own right now
1 / 3
Your turn

Start your own humidor.

@joshua.magalski has logged 24 cigars, mostly Padron. Snap a band and Cigarista names the cigar in seconds, then files it in your humidor with the specs filled in.

Two free identifications · No card · iPhone, Android & web

Your first cigarTap to scan the band