Cigarista Member

@edsmark128 — cigar collection & reviews

Premium Member
No. 00015Since MAY 2026
ED
Joined May 2026
The Case16 honors earned
Reached #1 · Reviewers
Hall of fame
Reached #1 · On Fire
Hall of fame
Reached #1 · Rising
Hall of fame
Cigarista Member
MAY 2026
50
Fifty Strong
Collection
Premium
MAY 2026
Board Honors10 earned
Reached #1 · Reviewers
Held the top spot on the Reviewers board.
Hall of fame
Reached #1 · On Fire
Held the top spot on the On Fire board.
Hall of fame
Reached #1 · Rising
Held the top spot on the Rising board.
Hall of fame
Top 10 ever · Collectors
Reached the top ten (#7) on the Collectors board.
Hall of fame
Top 10 ever · Explorers
Reached the top ten (#7) on the Explorers board.
Hall of fame
Board Mainstay · Collectors
Appeared on the Collectors board 50× or more.
Boards
Board Mainstay · Reviewers
Appeared on the Reviewers board 50× or more.
Boards
Board Mainstay · Explorers
Appeared on the Explorers board 50× or more.
Boards
Board Mainstay · Rising
Appeared on the Rising board 50× or more.
Boards
Board Fixture · On Fire
Appeared on the On Fire board 20× or more.
Boards
Right now
Currently #1 · Reviewers
The top spot on the Reviewers board right now.
Right now
Currently #1 · On Fire
The top spot on the On Fire board right now.
Right now
Currently top 10 · Rising
Among the top ten on the Rising board right now (#5).
Right now
Milestones4 earned
50
Fifty Strong
Logged 50 cigars to the ledger.
Collection
50
Fifty Reviews
Published 50 reviews.
Reviews
Brand Explorer
Logged cigars from 25 distinct brands.
Palate
Five-Origin Palate
Smoked across 5 countries of origin.
Palate
Streaks & Tenure2 earned
Cigarista Member
Member No. 00015.
Earned MAY 2026
Premium
Active Premium membership.
Earned MAY 2026
Every seal in @edsmark128’s case is earned, never given.
Climb the boards
The Private Ledger

@edsmark128keeps their cigar photos private. What follows is the public record of their taste — in their own words.

The Collection

54 cigars, mostly from Dominican Republic, with a taste for connecticut shade Robustos.
54
Cigars
55
Reviewed
3.3
Avg Rating
6
Day Streak

The Grails

Top 4· ranked by member
  1. 01
    Oliva
    Serie V Melanio Gran Reserva Limitada
    4.2
  2. 02
    Romeo y Julieta
    1875 Reserve
    4.4
  3. 03
    Arturo Fuente
    Gran Reserva
    4.4
  4. 04
    Arturo Fuente
    Arturo Fuente Hemingway
    4.9

Ratings

55 of 54 reviewed
3.3
Overall
of 5.0
Craftsmanship
3.3
Aroma & Flavor
3.3
Enjoyment
3.2
Distribution of Reviews44% rated 4★ or higher
31
22
2
1★
2★
3★
4★
5★

Top Brands

1
Arturo Fuente
13 cigars · 12 reviewed
3.0
2
Romeo y Julieta
9 cigars · 6 reviewed
3.5
3
Paul Garmirian
6 cigars · 6 reviewed
3.1
4
La Aroma de Cuba
5 cigars · 3 reviewed
3.9
5
H. Upmann
4 cigars · 3 reviewed
3.6

Collection DNA

what they reach for

Origin

Dominican Republic
66%·45 cigars
Nicaragua18%
Honduras9%

Wrapper

Connecticut Shade
31%·12 cigars
Cameroon15%
Maduro13%

Shape

Robusto
33%·20 cigars
Toro32%
Corona12%

Activity & Growth

Review Streak

6
days
running
Personal best: 6

Growth

+16
This Month
+68
This Year
16.5
Avg / Mo

Pace

Last reviewedToday
Last addedToday
Total reviews55

The Reviews

№ 01·SEP 20, 2026·Montecristo·Petit Robusto

White Series

4.0
smooth wrapperfirm drawconsistent ash
Full review
№ 02·SEP 19, 2026·H. Upmann·Robusto

The Banker Daytrader

4.5Would smoke again
even burn linesome minor veinsfirm consistent draw
Full review
№ 03·SEP 18, 2026·Romeo y Julieta·Corona

No. 3

3.4
visibly cracked wrapperdry appearanceaged look
Full review
№ 04·SEP 17, 2026·Romeo y Julieta·Robusto

1875 Reserve

4.4Would smoke again
firm constructioneven burn lineconsistent draw
Full review

The @edsmark128 Index

Humidor
54cigars
What they own right now
By brand
Arturo Fuente13
Romeo y Julieta9
Paul Garmirian6
La Aroma de Cuba5
H. Upmann4

Track your own collection

Identify any cigar, log your ratings, and curate your humidor. Cigarista is free to start; premium unlocks 35 IDs a month.

Sign up freeGet the app