Cigarista Member

@cmceachron — cigar collection & reviews

Premium Member
No. 00044Since SEP 2026
CM
Joined September 2026
The Case8 honors earned
Reached #1 · On Fire
Hall of fame
Cigarista Member
SEP 2026
Premium
SEP 2026
Top 10 ever · Rising
Hall of fame
Board Fixture · Rising
Boards
Board Regular · On Fire
Boards
Board Honors4 earned
Reached #1 · On Fire
Held the top spot on the On Fire board.
Hall of fame
Top 10 ever · Rising
Reached the top ten (#4) on the Rising board.
Hall of fame
Board Fixture · Rising
Appeared on the Rising board 20× or more.
Boards
Board Regular · On Fire
Appeared on the On Fire board 5× or more.
Boards
Right now
Currently top 10 · Rising
Among the top ten on the Rising board right now (#10).
Right now
Milestones2 earned
Brand Curious
Logged cigars from 10 distinct brands.
Palate
Five-Origin Palate
Smoked across 5 countries of origin.
Palate
Streaks & Tenure2 earned
Cigarista Member
Member No. 00044.
Earned SEP 2026
Premium
Active Premium membership.
Earned SEP 2026
Every seal in @cmceachron’s case is earned, never given.
Climb the boards

The Collection

20 cigars, mostly from Nicaragua, with a taste for maduro Toros.
20
Cigars
6
Reviewed
3.5
Avg Rating
—
Streak

Grails

1 cigar
Grail No. 1
Caldwell Cigar Co.
Caldwell Cigar Co. Lost & Found Just the Tip
5.0

Ratings

6 of 20 reviewed
3.5
Overall
of 5.0
Craftsmanship
3.5
Aroma & Flavor
3.5
Enjoyment
3.5
Distribution of Reviews50% rated 4★ or higher
1
2
2
1
1★
2★
3★
4★
5★

Top Brands

1
Caldwell Cigar Co.
5 cigars · 4 reviewed
3.5
2
Illusione
3 cigars
3
Drew Estate
2 cigars
4
Acid by Drew Estate
2 cigars · 1 reviewed
2.5
5
Alec Bradley
2 cigars

Collection DNA

what they reach for

Origin

Nicaragua
53%·10 cigars
Dominican Republic26%
Honduras11%

Wrapper

Maduro
23%·3 cigars
Habano15%
Nicaraguan Habano15%

Shape

Toro
40%·8 cigars
Robusto35%
Petit Corona10%

Activity & Growth

Review Streak

0
days
running
Personal best: 2

Growth

+0
This Month
+20
This Year
13.2
Avg / Mo

Pace

Last reviewed3 days ago
Last addedA month ago
Total reviews6

Latest reviews

Caldwell Cigar Co.
Caldwell Cigar Co. Lost & Found Just the Tip
Robusto
5.0

this was a good one. smooth yet robust. would totally buy again.

excellent constructiongood burneasy draw
Nov 1, 2026
Caldwell Cigar Co.
Caldwell Cigar Co. Lost & Found Cream Machine
Toro
4.2Would smoke again
excellent constructiongood burneasy draw
Oct 31, 2026
Caldwell Cigar Co.
Caldwell Cigar Co. Lost & Found Pepper Cream Soda
Robusto
2.2
Oct 11, 2026
Caldwell Cigar Co.
Caldwell Cigar Co. Yellow Cake Maduro Robusto Packs
Robusto
2.7Would smoke again
Oct 11, 2026
Acid by Drew Estate
Acid by Drew Estate Krush
Petit Corona
2.5Would smoke again
Oct 11, 2026
La Boutique del Fumador (Black Label Trading Co.) Black Abyss cigar
La Boutique del Fumador (Black Label Trading Co.)
Black Abyss
Toro
4.4

I really like this cigar

oily dark wrappersolid constructioneven burn line
Oct 4, 2026

More from @cmceachron

Humidor
What they own right now
1 / 3
Your turn

Start your own humidor.

@cmceachron has logged 20 cigars, mostly Caldwell Cigar Co.. Snap a band and Cigarista names the cigar in seconds, then files it in your humidor with the specs filled in.

Start freeiPhoneGoogle Play

Two free identifications · No card · iPhone, Android & web

Your first cigarTap to scan the band